Why is workforce spend managed by different rules?
Mostly through history. Workforce spend grew out of HR, so when it became a multi-million-pound platform and managed service contracts, ownership never moved to match.
The result is significant commercial contracts managed without commercial expertise. The fix isn't for procurement to take over, but to split the job the way other major categories already do.
The odd one out
When an organisation buys enterprise software of any real scale, procurement is involved almost automatically: security review, commercial terms, renewal governance. Nobody questions it.
But when that software is a platform for managing the workforce, it often stops being treated as software. It becomes "an HR system", and procurement may never get near it. The same happens with large managed service and contingent labour contracts. An equivalent contract in facilities or IT would sit with procurement without a second thought. The workforce version, worth as much and carrying as much commercial risk, frequently sits with HR or the business, with procurement nowhere in the room.
Same commercial characteristics. Different treatment. The main variable seems to be the word "workforce".
Why it happens
I don't think it's a deliberate decision. It's history, with some mechanics on top.
HR has existed far longer than procurement. As workforce spend quietly grew from hiring a few people into large platform and managed service contracts, it stayed where it had always lived. Nobody decided it should be exempt from commercial governance. It simply never occurred to anyone to move it.
There's a practical reason too. The workforce platform often isn't bought on its own. It arrives bundled inside a managed service contract, or the choice is left to the provider after the main contract is awarded. Either way, a significant piece of technology is selected outside any normal software buying process.
None of this is a criticism of HR. Managing people is what HR does, and does well. Commercial contract management is a different discipline.
Why it matters
When a major commercial contract is owned by a team that doesn't specialise in commercial management, the predictable happens. I've seen an acquisition where procurement wasn't allowed near the workforce suppliers or contracts. Afterwards, an error in one supplier arrangement turned out to have increased the cost. It's exactly the kind of thing a commercial review would very likely have caught before signature.
That's not a story about carelessness. It's a structural problem: a commercial task handled by people whose expertise lies elsewhere.
What good looks like
The answer is the model that already works for every other category:
- Procurement leads on strategy, contracting and commercial governance.
- HR or the business owns the day-to-day operational relationship.
Think of a chef and a waiter. Both jobs matter, but they aren't the same job, and you wouldn't ask one person to do both.
Some organisations run workforce spend entirely through HR and do it well, usually because they've built real commercial capability inside the team. Others hand everything to procurement and the operational relationship suffers. The balance is what matters.
What to do next
- List your largest workforce-related contracts: MSP, VMS, master vendor and major agency agreements.
- Check who negotiated each one, and who governs it now.
- Find out when each is due for renewal, and whether that's on anyone's radar.
- Agree a simple split of responsibilities between procurement and HR.
- Make sure platform choices get a proper technology and commercial review, even inside a managed service.
How I can help
I help organisations review and re-tender workforce contracts, set up the right split of ownership between procurement and HR, and choose the right technology.
A first conversation, on me
Tell me what's going on with your business. You'll come away with a clearer view of your options, whether or not we work together.




