Are you hiring a person or buying an outcome?

19 October 2026

When a gap appears, the reflex is usually "we need someone", followed by a call to an agency. That works for some roles, but for project work it often means paying for time rather than results. Asking whether you need someone present or something delivered is the quickest way to choose the right approach.


Two ways to engage external people


Time-based. You engage a temporary worker or contractor at an hourly or daily rate, usually through an agency. It's familiar and flexible, but you pay for effort, and the cost depends on how long the work takes.


Outcome-based. You agree what will be delivered, by when and for how much, usually in a statement of work (SOW). The supplier is accountable for delivering it. You pay for results, not hours.


Outcome-based agreements have been around for a long time, but they were mostly used for consultancy and specialist projects. Because the workforce industry grew out of recruitment, many organisations still default to hiring people, even when what they really need is a piece of work done.


An outcome-based engagement is more than a SOW


The SOW is the document. The outcome-based approach runs through the whole engagement: defining the need, agreeing deliverables and milestones, tracking delivery, approving it and reconciling payment. If only the paperwork changes and the way the work is managed doesn't, you're still paying for time.


A quick test


Before you engage anyone, ask:


  • Do you need someone present, or something delivered?
  • Do you want flexibility in daily tasks, or accountability for results?
  • Are you managing a person, or managing performance?
  • Can you describe what "done" looks like?
  • Could a supplier decide how the work gets done?


If the outcome is clear, the work is project-based and the "how" can be left to the supplier, an outcome-based approach is likely to be the better fit. If you need someone to cover a role or follow day-to-day direction, a temporary worker probably is.




Imagine you bring in a contractor at £75 an hour to support a project expected to take five months, around 1,000 hours. The budget is £75,000.


The project shifts, the work grows, the contractor fits in well and picks up other tasks, and the engagement is extended. Six months later you've spent £100,000 and the original goal still hasn't been met.


Now flip it. You define the outcome and agree a fixed price of £85,000 for delivery, perhaps with a bonus for finishing early and a deduction for delays. The supplier owns delivery, and you own a predictable cost.


Why it's worth considering


  • Predictable costs. The total is agreed upfront, so overruns become the supplier's problem.
  • Clearer accountability. Suppliers are responsible for quality and deadlines.
  • Better compliance. Engagements built around genuine deliverables are easier to defend on IR35 and off-payroll rules, as long as the work is really delivered that way.
  • Flexibility. You bring in expertise for a defined piece of work without adding headcount.


Outcome-based agreements don't suit everything. For short-term cover, a temporary worker is usually right. The point is to choose deliberately, rather than by default.


What to do next


  1. Look at your current contractor engagements and ask which are really projects.
  2. Run the quick test above on new requests before they go to an agency.
  3. Start with one or two pilot projects with clear deliverables.
  4. Agree how delivery will be tracked and approved, not just how the SOW is written.
  5. Compare the total cost with what the time-based route would have cost.


How I can help



I help organisations work out which engagements suit an outcome-based approach, set up SOW processes that work, and help staffing agencies offer SOW-based services.


How I support businesses

A first conversation, on me

Tell me what's going on with your business. You'll come away with a clearer view of your options, whether or not we work together.

More Insights

Document icon on a teal background, illustrating governance of workforce contracts
22 October 2026
Large workforce platform and managed service contracts often bypass procurement. Why it happens, why it matters and what a better split of ownership looks like.
Laptop showing a chart on a teal background, illustrating external workforce spend visibility
21 October 2026
Why external workforce spend is so hard to pull together, the four barriers that usually get in the way, and how to tackle each with or without new technology.
Hard hat icon on a teal background, illustrating choosing the right engagement model
20 October 2026
Employee, temporary worker, contractor, SOW or outcome-based engagement? A practical guide to choosing the right model before you engage anyone.
Connected network icon on a teal background, illustrating off-contract hiring
18 October 2026
Why managers bypass agreed staffing suppliers, what off-contract hiring really costs, and four practical ways to bring it back under control.