Why do legacy staffing models win by default?
Because they're familiar, raising a request, getting a person and signing timesheets is a process everyone understands, so it feels safe even when it isn't the best fit for the work. Choosing the right engagement model starts with recognising that habit, and asking what the work actually needs.
Familiarity feels safe. Fit takes a little effort.
I've played cricket for most of my life, and for years I bought the same make of bat every time. I didn't compare prices or try anything else. It felt safe, so I stuck with it. When I finally looked around, I found a bat that gave me more control, cost less and helped me play better.
Engaging external people works the same way. Contingent staffing is the model most organisations know: a request, a person, a timesheet for plenty of roles that's exactly right. But "familiar" and "right" aren't the same thing, and defaulting to the familiar model for every need can cost more than it seems.
Why "fill the seat" keeps winning.
The staffing model fits neatly into existing HR and procurement processes. It gives a sense of control, because you can see who's doing what and for how long. And it feels low risk. Nobody gets questioned for bringing in another contractor, but a service engagement that goes wrong attracts attention.
The result is a pattern I see regularly:
- Scope creeps, and nobody is clearly accountable.
- Projects run past their deadlines.
- Contractors are renewed out of habit, not because of the value they're delivering.
The issue is rarely the people. It's the model.
The real barriers are about mindset.
"We've always done it this way." Processes don't get questioned until they fail.
Organisations are built around people, not outcomes. Budgets, approvals and contracts are usually set up for headcount and rates, not deliverables.
We're used to buying time. Having someone on site or in meetings feels like progress, even if nothing has been delivered yet.
Managers like to manage. Handing the "how" to a supplier can feel uncomfortable, but managing every detail doesn't scale.
Choosing fit over familiarity
This isn't about abandoning contingent staffing. It has its place. But when the goal is to solve a problem, deliver a project or create something new, the engagement model should reflect that, with:
- defined deliverables
- fixed or milestone-based pricing
- clear accountability
- freedom for the supplier to decide how the work is done
It takes some work upfront to scope and contract properly, but it pays off with predictable costs, better compliance, and better results.
Questions to ask yourself
- Are you hiring a person, or buying a result?
- Is your current approach giving you clarity, or just comfort?
- Would you rather see someone busy, or see real progress?
What to do next
- List your current external engagements and the model each one uses.
- Flag the ones that have been extended more than once.
- For each, ask whether the work is really a defined project.
- Look at what's stopping you from using a different model: budgets, approvals, contracts or habit.
- Try an outcome-based approach on one suitable piece of work.
How I can help
I help organisations choose the right engagement model for each type of work, and help staffing agencies and MSPs offer outcome-based services alongside traditional supply.
A first conversation, on me
Tell me what's going on with your business. You'll come away with a clearer view of your options, whether or not we work together.









