Are you engaging external people the right way?
Misclassification isn't just about IR35. It happens whenever work is engaged through the wrong model: a contractor brought in when you needed a delivery partner, or a consultancy that ends up operating like a staffing agency. It's rarely deliberate. It usually comes from urgency and habit, and it's easiest to fix at the very start.
Routine can hide risk.
For years I renewed my home insurance on autopilot. When I finally read the policy, I realised it no longer covered the things that mattered most. I'd been paying for peace of mind, not actual cover.
Engaging external people can work the same way. A need comes up, and the reflex kicks in: open the system, apply the rate card, copy the standard contract. When nobody pauses to define what's really needed, the wrong model gets locked in, and everything that follows suffers.
How it happens
A new project lands, someone says "we need help", and before anyone steps back, the process is already moving:
- a contractor is hired when a delivery partner was needed
- a consultancy steps in but ends up working like a staffing supplier
- a time-based contract is signed, even though the goal was a defined outcome
Sometimes it works out. But governance often catches it after the fact, and by then the risk is already built in.
It's not only a tax question.
IR35 and off-payroll rules make the headlines, but the root of misclassification usually sits further upstream:
- Who's starting the engagement, and why?
- Are we buying time, tasks or a result?
- Is there a clear line between the supplier's people and our own employees?
Those questions have a compliance side, but they're just as much commercial and operational. Get them wrong, and you see missed outcomes, higher costs, frustrated teams and less trust between departments.
The early warning signs
The red flags tend to show up early:
- vague scopes
- unclear accountability
- contracts drafted for speed rather than clarity
All of them are fixable.
Three fixes at the start
A sharper intake. Before sourcing anything, ask what's needed: a person to fill a role, or a piece of work to be delivered.
Clear ownership. Agree who owns delivery, who manages the supplier and who signs off the work.
A shared definition of success. Agree what good looks like before the contract is drafted, so the contract reflects it.
A little rigour at the beginning saves a lot of unpicking later. One small decision at the start often shapes the whole engagement.
What to do next
- Add three simple triage questions to how new external requests are raised.
- Review long-running engagements for signs the model no longer fits.
- Check that contracts reflect how the work is actually being done.
- Make sure hiring managers understand the difference between engaging a worker and buying a service.
- Agree who to go to when a request falls into a grey area.
How I can help
I help organisations set up simple triage for external requests, choose the right engagement model, and ensure contracts stand up to IR35 and off-payroll rules.
A first conversation, on me
Tell me what's going on with your business. You'll come away with a clearer view of your options, whether or not we work together.









